‘Promises not kept’: Dallas ISD votes to close 6 schools amid budget shortfall

A divided Dallas ISD board voted Thursday night to close six schools as the district faces a $128 million shortfall.
The decision was made despite emotional pleas from parents and community members to save J.J. Rhoads Early Learning Center in South Dallas.
“One thing history teaches us is… promises made and promises not kept,” resident Alpha Thomas told trustees.
For Thomas and other community members, the decision brought back memories of earlier school closures and raised questions about whether the district was abandoning its commitment to South Dallas.
The three Black trustees on the board – Byron Sanders, Joyce Foreman and Ed Turner – opposed closing Rhoads, arguing the district was giving up on a successful early childhood program it had promised the community.
Trustees voted 6-3 to reject Turner’s motion to give Rhoads a separate vote. A later effort to postpone the decision until December also failed.
Along with J.J. Rhoads Early Learning Center, N.W. Harllee Early Childhood Center, Harrell Budd Elementary School, Ignacio Zaragoza Elementary School and Boude Storey Middle School are also slated to close at the end of the school year.
Arlington Park Early Childhood Center closed earlier this year.
District officials said Boude Storey and Harrell Budd have struggled academically for years, raising concerns about possible state intervention. Zaragoza was selected because of declining enrollment and facility considerations.
The three early learning centers were chosen because Dallas ISD now offers full-day pre-K at nearly all its elementary schools, reducing the need for standalone programs.

A fight to save J.J. Rhoads
J.J. Rhoads has served generations of South Dallas families since 1955. Today, it offers pre-K for 3- and 4-year-olds, with 122 students enrolled in a program designed for 130.
Attorney Calvin Johnson, whose daughter attended Rhoads, questioned why the school was on the closure list.
“How is enrollment low if you have 122 students and 130 slots?” Johnson asked trustees.
He said the decision revived longstanding concerns about the district’s treatment of South Dallas.
Julia C. Frazier Elementary closed in 2012, followed by Pearl C. Anderson Middle School in 2013, as part of an earlier round of district consolidations. Johnson said those closures damaged the community’s trust in Dallas ISD.
“If you close Joseph J. Rhoads, do you think South Dallas is going to ever trust you again?” he asked. “We’re not going to.”

Trustee Byron Sanders said Rhoads represents a commitment the district made after past closures.
When H.S. Thompson closed in 2019, its students moved to Rhoads, which eventually stopped operating as an elementary school. South Dallas residents at the time urged the district to turn the campus into an early childhood center.
Rhoads reopened as a pre-K center in 2021.
In 2024, Dallas ISD added Resource Center South, funded through the district’s 2020 bond package. The center offers a food pantry, mental health counseling, job training and assistance applying for public benefits.
Sanders said the pantry alone has served as many as 280 families in a busy week.
“Today, Rhoads is a front door for South Dallas families,” Sanders said. “A parent can drop off a three-year-old and get groceries, counseling, or help with paperwork in the same building.”
District officials said children at Rhoads can move about a mile and a half away to H.S. Thompson Elementary. The students will keep the same teachers and be in similar classrooms. The resource center will remain open at Rhoads.
The move is projected to save between $1.2 million and $1.4 million annually. But Sanders questioned the savings because the district will still have to maintain the building.
Community leader and former Dallas City Council member Diane Ragsdale urged trustees to honor the district’s earlier commitment.

“We are not simply asking you to keep our school building open,” Ragsdale said. “We’re asking you to preserve an educational opportunity, to protect a vital community resource and to honor a promise made to the families of South Dallas.”
Split vote

Trustee Ed Turner, whose district includes Rhoads, questioned why the school was selected when enrollment has increased in recent years and the program has performed well academically.
He also asked about other specialized campuses operating at a deficit. District officials identified more than 10, including Martin Luther King Jr. Arts Academy and Solar Preparatory School for Boys.
But Trustee Lance Currie supported moving Rhoads students to H.S. Thompson, saying they would have the same teachers, curriculum and classroom experience.
“I am struggling to see how the student experience will be less from what I am seeing,” Currie said.
Trustee Joyce Foreman disagreed, saying the district was overlooking the community’s concerns.
“We’re telling you what we want and you’re telling us what we need,” Foreman said. “That’s not what we wanted.”
Ultimately the board voted 6-3 to approve the closures.

More budget cuts could be coming
Dallas ISD began the school year facing a projected $104 million deficit. That figure has since grown to approximately $128 million after enrollment came in about 3,100 students below projections, according to district staff.
The six closures are expected to save about $10 million annually, leaving most of the shortfall unresolved.
KERA contacted all Dallas ISD school board members to ask what other reductions the district might consider.
Only Trustee Dan Micciche responded by the deadline. He acknowledged that additional cuts would be necessary but said decisions about where to make them would be up to the superintendent.
Dallas ISD said it is too early to determine which programs, services or positions could be affected. The district said decisions about additional budget reductions will be finalized in the spring as part of its annual budgeting process.
This article originally appeared in KERA at https://www.kera.org/2026/11/20/dallas-isd-votes-close-six-schools-jj-rhoads-budget/.
Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

Sujata Dand is an award-winning journalist who is energized by change brought in communities in response to news stories. She lives in and has spent most of her reporting career in Dallas, with ample experience covering health care, education and public policy.
“I think it’s important to elevate voices that are often ignored,” Dand says. “For me, that means meeting the people in our communities. We need to see people and listen to them. It’s often a huge act of courage for people to openly share their lives. So, I feel an enormous responsibility in making sure my stories are authentic and fair.”
Dand worked at KERA for almost 10 years, where she produced several television documentaries, including “Life in the Balance: The Health Care Crisis in Texas” and “High School: The Best and the Rest.” She also headed the multimedia project “Boyfriends,” which examined the complex personal and cultural factors that contribute to the way adolescent girls form and maintain relationships. Her work has garnered several local Emmys and national awards including a Gracie for best reality program.
Prior to her work with KERA, Sujata was a reporter and anchor at the CBS affiliate in Wichita Falls, Texas. She has worked as a freelance reporter for NPR and Dallas Morning News. Dand is a graduate of Trinity University in San Antonio.
Areas of Expertise:
health care, education, public policy
Location Expertise:
Dallas, Texas
Official Title:
Senior Editor and Reporter
Email Address:
sujata@dallasfreepress.com



